Saturday, January 4, 2014

Ok. It's been a long time since I've written anything here, but last night I was struck by an inspiration to rant.

So I was watching Avatar, (The James Cameron one, not the animated one) and something hit me, while the movie is excellent. Beautiful visuals, decent acting, a really good musical score, all that jazz. I realized that the Final Battle at the Tree of Souls, the big epic climax of the movie, is one of the worst military fiascos of cinema history.

Main character Jake Sully quite literally has every possible advantage in this battle with the exception of technology. He has Numerical Superiority, he and his warriors know the terrain that they are fighting in like the back of their hands. They had warning of the enemy's activity before the Marines even left their base. He has the advantage of the terrain working against the enemy thanks to that awesome magnetic field that screws with electronics. He knows exactly what the Marines are trying to do, he knows exactly how they're planning to do it, he even knows the exact route the Marine's gunships have to take to reach their objective. And on top of all of that, he's a God Damned MARINE HIMSELF! He knows Marine tactics, he knows Marine psychology, so how? HOW? How the hell does he get his ASS kicked so damned hard? I mean come the hell on!

Correct me if I'm wrong here, but aren't Marines trained at military academies in such things as TACTICS?! Jake Sully's academy instructors were probably rolling in their graves during this battle. He has almost every conceivable advantage he could possibly have without hacking reality and turning on God Mode, and what does he do? He let's the marines get to within spitting distance of the Tree before attacking, and then throws his forces at the marines head on, trusting that a frontal assault with superior numbers will "do the trick". Only actually "Winning" the battle thanks to some rather timely Divine Intervention. Just about the only thing he did right was how he used his flyers.

Wrong. Wrong. Wrong. WRONG! I mean come on, I can make a better battle plan than that. Here, I'll show you: "Ok, we have 2000 Navi warriors, armed with bows, spears, daggers, and a seething hatred for just about all things human. We know that the enemy will be here tomorrow morning. Well then, I'll have a group of hunters, well versed in stealth and silent kills set up in ambush in various locations that I believe the marines will  land their troops. That way, while they are landing, and are therefore less organized and less ready for an attack, my hunters will strike from the shadows, killing as many humans as they can before falling back to a new position. Next I'll make use of the rather impressive number of cavalry troops I have, as well as the natural cover of the Forest foliage, and the less than stellar scanners then enemy will be forced to use thanks to the "Flux Vortex" and have my cavalry flank and out-mannuver the enemy. Thus making their (at the moment) superior firepower, more or less useless. As for Trudy and her awesome little gunship that we have on our side, I wont let her take on that big gunship in a head to head knock-down-drag-out fight. She will use her superior manoverability and speed, to take out the big gunship the way it should be done, from behind and from the sides."

There. a better, smarter battle plan than Jake Sully's. And I work at a freaking gas station.

No comments:

Post a Comment