My fellow One Piece fans, I come before you today to posit a theory.
My theory is a simple one; I believe that anyone is capable of eating more than one Devil Fruit, not just Marshal D. "Blackbeard" Teach.
Now of course, I know the first thing that springs to mind is "But it's been stated that it's impossible hasn't it?" And yes, technically, we have been 'told' that "If you eat two Devil Fruit, you will explode and die." However this is where my theory comes from actually. If you stop and think, the only people thus far in the series who have explicitly stated that a person cannot eat a second Devil Fruit have been people working for the World Government. This is important as it is the central point of my argument, however something else to note is that when Rob Lucci, Blueno and Jabbra are discussing the disadvantages of eating multiple Fruits, they refer to legends, myths, and rumors as the source of their knowledge.
http://vignette4.wikia.nocookie.net/onepiece/images/e/ef/Jabra_Gets_Close_to_Devil_Fruits.png/revision/latest?cb=20131206044455
Now on to the big point. The only people who have stated that "You cannot eat two Devil Fruit", have been employees of the World Government. We all know that the WG get's up to some seriously shady shit, especially if it is in defense of their power and influence over the world. Lies, murder, extortion, kidnapping, slavery, and countless other utterly inhumane, downright evil acts are the standard by which the WG operates.
So what does this mean for our theory? Simple. The belief that you cannot eat two Devil Fruit is just a lie propagated by the World Government. The pieces fall into place fairly well when you consider that Eiichiro Oda is a master at setting up story plots years in advance, (See the Vinsmoke family if you don't believe me,) and that he never does things on accident.
Rob Lucci is the living epitome of the "shady shit" side of the World Government, a man who's biggest claim to fame within the series continuity was the merciless slaughter of 500 soldiers and a full pirate crew (He was 13 at the time by the way). This is an important fact, because he is basically the embodiment of the World Government and what they will do in order to protect their own interests. And that embodiment is the one who told us, "No, you cannot have two Devil Fruits at once."
https://i.ytimg.com/vi/Zmais4kGwaQ/hqdefault.jpg
So why is this important? It matters, because this is the analogy for the World Government's lie to the world. Think about it: The Devil Fruits are some of the most powerful weapons in the world. Eat the right one, and you wield the fundamental powers of creation at your fingertips. Now imagine that you are a newly formed World Government; You've just accomplished the impossible, uniting the world under a single banner, (presumably with the use of some seriously shady shit, given how the Sages of Ohara acted just before they were all murdered by agents of the same World Government.) Now if I were a newly formed world order, and I wanted to ensure that I STAYED as the world order for a while, I would do everything in my power to limit the danger posed by possible enemies in the future. Not just twenty or thirty years on, no. I would be looking at the Long Game. And how do you do that? Well there are several ways, sure, and I would use every single possible one of them. And the easiest method for an organization that controls the world is propaganda. Begin telling the world that these magical fruits that give you incredible powers at the cost of your ability to swim come with a caveat; you can't ever eat more than one, or you die. Jump forward 800 years, and we get Rob Lucci, the physical embodiment of the World Government's shady, underhanded, murderous side, telling the audience the lie that the World Government has been telling for hundreds of years.
Then, just a few volumes later, one man proves that lie wrong in the space of a single chapter. Marshal D. Teach is a brilliant man, he's dangerous, he's unpredictable, he's ambitious, and above all, he is patient. But for all that, we know very little about him. We know that he is one of the few people to give "Red Hair" Shanks a visible scar, we know that he was a member of Whitebeard's pirate crew for at least ten years, and we know that he studied Devil Fruits extensively. He memorized the published 'Book of Devil Fruits' in his younger years in his search for the Yami Yami no Mi, and he joined the Whitebeard Pirates expressly to search for the same fruit. In all that time, he probably realized that the concept of not being able to eat multiple fruits was a lie. However, he didn't tell anyone else for one very important reason.
http://i.imgur.com/ypWFAFk.jpg
Marshal D. Teach is a grandstander. He's a showman. He want's to be the one who changes the world and stick his name on the era. He said it himself, after revealing that he had the powers of two Devil Fruit, "This is My Age!" He realized that if he told people that you can eat multiple Devil Fruits and not die, not only would most people not believe him, since he was contradicting an 800 year old 'truth', but the World Government would use any means to silence him. So instead, he bided his time, stayed firmly in the background where nobody would notice him, and waited for the perfect moment to appear before the world and proclaim "Look! This is what the Government fears most."
And what better way to declare a revolution against the world than by acting like you have an ability that makes you truly unique. Even if that 'ability' is just something that everyone has, but has been hidden away by lies and propaganda on a truly Orwellian scale. By making a public spectacle of the truth, and doing so using two of the most dangerous and powerful Devil Fruits on record, Teach ensured that not only did the whole world see the truth, and the World Government wouldn't be able to silence him easily, but he did so in a way that would attract numerous followers seeking the "Secret" of how to eat multiple Devil Fruit. Thus ensuring that he would have the forces to face the inevitable retribution he would face from the World Government.
So what do you guys think? Am I crazy, seeing connections where there are none? Or have I caught one of Eiichiro Oda Sensei's best kept secrets?























